• Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Snapchat
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

MsMarmiteLover

  • Food
    • Recipes
    • Vegetarian
    • Vegan
  • Travel
    • France
    • Italy
    • Spain
    • UK
  • Wine
  • Gardens
  • Supperclubs/Events
  • About
    • Published Articles
    • Books
  • Shop
    • Cart

Patrick O’Brian night at The Underground Restaurant

February 9, 2010 6 Comments Filed Under: Food, Recipes, Uncategorized

Stargazy pie

Quail’s egg shells

Blind Scouse

Ship’s Biscuit
Stargazy pie: ‘canoed’ herrings, that is, they have been de-boned from the top.

Stargazy pie before baking
Steaming the pease pudding

Vegetarian Suet
Isn’t the baby cute? Weighed about 9lbs.
Feet first!

Wrapped tightly in a cloth, looking like Moses in the rushes, boil/steam for at least two and a half hours


“You’re late!” I barked opening the door at 8.30pm.

The two young pretty girls standing there in the cold trembled, made as if to go away. “Sorry, sorry” they whimpered.

“All right then you can come in” I allowed grumpily, beckoning them in “we’ll just have to put the table back. You’ve missed the first course”

They ducked in, still apologising, gabbling about transport problems.

“Don’t worry about the first course, if you like” they said in their piping voices.

Ross, Scottish Front of house, swivelled into the living room, carrying a 2 person table over the heads of the diners, plonking it down in front of the fire. The girls sat down obediently, coats still on, as table cloth, napkins, cutlery were gradually placed on the table. Two glasses of grog were dolled out.

“No. It’s fine.” I said with an air of martyrdom.

Only later did I realise they were also supperclub hosts ‘Altenburg Kitchen’. I didn’t recognise them. My daughter said to me

“Mum you can’t talk to guests as if they are your children. It’s not me coming in late after a night out.”

I felt a bit sheepish. I’m getting bossier. I find myself telling guests off all the time. On Burns night I had to tell the whole room off for taking more than one welcome drink. I remonstrated with one woman for not eating up all her dinner. This night Ross told me somebody complained about corkage and the price of the meal. (My teen said afterwards “never tell mum stuff like this, you don’t know what it’ll lead to”).

I reacted with outrage “What does she look like?”.

Armed with a description I marched out to the living room and confronted said diner with

“I told you there was corkage beforehand. It was listed on the website. Plus it’s not expensive”.

The poor woman, taken aback, said “it wasn’t me, it was her” pointing to her companion.

Who then said “It is expensive”.

“NO IT ISN’T’ I insisted “plus if you thought it was, why did you book?” I finished with triumphant logic.

She had no answer to that. In the end she thoroughly enjoyed it, despite a tongue mauling by moi.
Quite a few guests came in pirate or sailor gear, one with a plastic swashbuckling sword; the police laughed at her ‘dangerous weapon’ when she was spotted exiting the tube.
The final menu:
Grog (the original recipe suggested half a cup of rum, a little sugar, ginger, cochineal and hot water. Each. Naturally I diluted these proportions)
Blind Scouse soup.
Carrots, onions, leeks, pearl barley, butterbeans and various strange spices such as juniper berries, mace and all spice.
Hard tack or Ships Biscuit.
I didn’t bake these the prerequisite (if they were to last five years at sea) four times. Once was enough. I announced that any dentistry problems would be at guest’s own risk. Bizarrely some people liked them and asked for more. It was very difficult to knead the dense dough, folding it repeatedly into layers, one recipe suggested driving over the dough (in a bag) in a car.
Stargazy pie.
This was spectacular, theatrical food. Combining a few recipes together (some have pastry on the bottom, some don’t) eventually it was comprised of herrings, quails eggs, cream, white wine, carrots and onions. James of @mycotswoldfood made shortcrust pastry and constructed them while I got on with the rest of the prep. I can see why they are not on menus all the time as it’s very time consuming to make them. However it was well worth the effort. I added pastry stars and a moon on top and moulded the edges into wave-like shapes.
Dog’s Body:
or pease pudding. This took hours to cook, steaming in a tea towel. It’s the equivalent of dhal or hummus. I mixed the pease with copious amounts of butter.
Cheese board of Oatcakes, honey, Edam cheese and Cheshire cheese.
The original story behind Edam’s red wax skins is that the cheese was hung over cow dung to mature. The ammonia from the dung would stain the wax red. Edam and Cheshire were both authentic shipboard cheeses as I could not obtain ‘Flet’ cheese which is no longer made.
‘Boiled baby’
served with James’ superbly light custard to which I added rosewater. Rosewater was frequently used in the 18th century in much the same way that vanilla is nowadays. The boiled baby, a very heavy suet pudding, took hours of steaming. It was the sort of thing you’d really want to eat if you’d spent several bells up the rigging in a force ten gale. I had soaked the sultanas in sherry to add an alcoholic kick.

Coffee with ratafia biscuits
which were incredibly easy to make. Ground almonds, almond essence, rosewater and egg white.
Many of my recipes were sourced and adapted from this fascinating book ‘Lobscouse and Spotted Dog‘ by mother and daughter team Anne Grossman and Lisa Grossman Thomas based on the work of Patrick O’Brian.
This girl had to be given step by step instructions how to put a record on. When the music finished, Ross the waiter said “we need another record”. “Why don’t you put the other side on?” I asked. He said with surprise“There’s another side?!” I was looking at him wondering if he was taking the piss/remedially stupid, then realised, of course, that CDs only play on one side. Youngsters eh?
It was great to work with and learn from James Benson, a gentle giant, previously a sous chef at Claridges and now located in the Cotswolds. Here’s his website and his blog (in my blog roll). He now caters for private dinners, weddings and tourists, the latter a great idea for mothers on self-catering holidays because it’s not exactly a break for them if they are still doing all the cooking like at home. James is used to adapting to different kitchens. Judging by the quality of his cooking, his sauces in particular were fantastic, I couldn’t recommend him more highly. The prices are damn reasonable too. We talked about the difficulty of making a living in food when you can’t sell alcohol as restaurants tend to make most profit on drink.

Link to Lucy Inglis’ Georgian London formspring

What would be a typical Georgian meal?

If you were going out to a pub or inn during the day, they served a thing called ‘the ordinary’, which was the hot dish of the day, or it would have meant cold meats and cheese on a sideboard, with a small salad selection.

If you ate in, it would be common to have a soup or a fish course, even it was just a couple of grilled or pickled herring/oysters, followed by dressed meat of some description or a pie served hot. It was good drills to have at least one salad and a crisply cooked green vegetable. Not so different to us now really. Portions weren’t enormous, so when you see loads of different dishes on a table, it doesn’t mean it amounted to gargantuan amounts of food. I can PDF you Hannah Glasse’s Art of Cookery if you like. @msmarmitelover

Recent posts

Cheap eats in London

October 23, 2025

Blueberry galette recipe

July 14, 2025

High protein recipes: roast tofu block

July 2, 2025

Previous Post: « Ahoy there! Wine, women and war
Next Post: Cocaine, blancmange and Suzi Q »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. The Curious Cat

    February 10, 2010 at 1:49 pm

    The pie really goes look like something special! How marvellous! 🙂 xxx

    Reply
  2. Sarah, Maison Cupcake

    February 10, 2010 at 2:47 pm

    Your menus are always so lovingly researched, I would never ever think of eating any of these things unprompted but I am sure I would enjoy everything if I came. Must admit I'm a bit scared now though!!

    Reply
  3. theundergroundrestaurant

    February 11, 2010 at 10:26 am

    It's true, I am a complete ogre.

    Reply
  4. Helen

    February 11, 2010 at 9:01 pm

    I am part Cornish and stargazy pie has a very special place in my heart. I have pictures of it hanging in my house. Many happy memories.

    Reply
  5. Ben

    February 19, 2010 at 12:56 pm

    Good work on the pie! Definitely worth the effort isn't it?

    Reply
  6. theundergroundrestaurant

    February 19, 2010 at 1:40 pm

    Yes Ben and thanks for your inspiration to put pastry stars on top!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Primary Sidebar

MsMarmiteLover aka Kerstin Rodgers.

Chef, photographer, author, journalist, blogger. Pioneer of the supperclub movement.

This is my food and travel blog, with recipes, reviews and travel stories. I also stray into politics, feminism, gardening.

msmarmitelover

My first upholstery project: a nursing rocking cha My first upholstery project: a nursing rocking chair. I used pink toile de jouey fabric and stuffed the seat and back. I used brass tacks. Did a 2 day course at Morley college. I wrote about my love of repair, vintage fabrics on my substack: https://kerstinrodgers.substack.com/p/shoes-fabric-hand-made-craft-repair
Last night made a French onion soup with toasted c Last night made a French onion soup with toasted cheese on top and lots of white wine. Perfect food for zero degrees 🧤🧦🧣❄️recipe: half a dozen brown onions sliced thinly softened in olive oil. 5 cloves garlic crushed and added once the onions are soft. Several fresh bay leaves. 3 vag nope I meant veg stock cubes and 1.5 litres of hot water. 1/3 bottle white wine or a glass of dry sherry. Or both. Simmer for a while then add sourdough bread topped with grated cheese at the end. I used cheddar. Serve hot, sprinkle parsley if you have it and good black pepper. I used kampot black peppercorns. #winterfood #soup #homecooking
I did a private afternoon tea supper club yesterda I did a private afternoon tea supper club yesterday. Thanks to @bro0907 and @imogenrodgersofficial for their help #london #afternoontea #supperclub
I went to a pre Christmas event at @themontgomerie I went to a pre Christmas event at @themontgomeriegarden hotel in Bloomsbury last night. It was hosted by the German tourist board promoting Saxony. I saw mini workshops of crafts from Nuremberg- these little 25 point Moravian paper stars ( each one takes an hour to make), finely whittled & carved wooden Christmas decorations , @meissen_germany porcelain, smoking wooden figurines ( filled with incense, nutcrackers, authentic stollen, Nuremberg ginger bread, white mulled wine and some lovely canapés. Going to try to make a stollen myself. You must always cut it in the middle, so you can put it together so it doesn’t get stale. I found out Colditz, the famous TV drama is in Saxons. I’d love to visit. It all got me in the Christmas mood @visit_germany @visitsaxony_ @visitdresden #christmas #stöllen #germanyinlondon
Making almond chocolate dipped biscotti for Saturd Making almond chocolate dipped biscotti for Saturdays Tea party supper club. Recipe from my tea and baking book Msmarmitelover’s secret tea party. #baking #london #biscotti
At the book launch for Pornocracy by Jo Bartosch w At the book launch for Pornocracy by Jo Bartosch with co-author Robert Jessel speaking, looked on by feminist campaigners Maya Forstater @hiyamayahiya and @fionamcanena of @sexmattersorg . The latter wrote Terf Island. This looks like an Old Master painting. This took place @womensuniversityclub a beautiful private members club in london for women. Historic women who’ve changed the law. Left to right: Robert Jessel, Jo Bartosch, Maya Forstater and Fiona Mcanena. #london #authors #womensrights
On the secret platform of the jubilee line at Char On the secret platform of the jubilee line at Charing Cross, now disused, we were treated to a fabulous cheese inspired fashion show by the fashion students of @ualfoundation and @3ddafoundation The cheeses featured were cantal, comté, tomme de savoie, saint nectaire, fourme d’ambert, époisses, Brills-savaging, Camembert, Brie and langres. The outfits were so creative and deeply researched by the designers. @thecheeseexplorer explained that during the tastings, some designers had never tasted those cheeses before. Anglo French @tatty_macleod came and is one of the judges. It was surreal and fun. Afterwards we were treated to a groaning cheese platter table at the bottom of the escalators. Then I joined the commuters of the london tube journeying home. Food and fashion are often opposed: to be fashionable you must not eat. This turns it on its head. @hopscotch_season #london #cheese #fashionandfood #cheesesoffrance
Sunday lunch autumn vibes: munchkin pumpkin blue c Sunday lunch autumn vibes: munchkin pumpkin blue cheese soufflés; baked fish stuffed with dates ( an adaptation of @ghilliebasan’s recipe in The Moroccan cookbook) with couscous and almonds; roast potatoes, carrots with preserved bergamot: mile high filo pear pie: open fire and candles and family #cooking #family #london #sundaylunch
Took Ophelia @ophelia.rose.2022 to @kenwood_house_ Took Ophelia @ophelia.rose.2022 to @kenwood_house_hampstead_heath for the Halloween trail. It was a little bit scary & I had to shoot & hold her hand at the same time. It’s a lit trail around the gardens and house with food, performances and set pieces. #grandma #london #outings #grandmacore #halloween #thingstodoinlondon
my latest substack post https://kerstinrodgers.sub my latest substack post https://kerstinrodgers.substack.com/p/rad-fems-by-the-seaside-filia-25 on attending the Filia feminist conference in Brighton. It was full of controversy: violent protests by trans activists, splits between feminists over anti-semitism. Also talks on surrogacy with testimony, on the Spy Cops case where women were deceived into long term relationships by married undercover cops, plus my observations of the conference.
Just had this window built by @odgjoinery and stai Just had this window built by @odgjoinery and stained glass window to match the front door by @wstoneglass beautiful work. Thank you so much. #edwardianhouse #victorianhome #stainedglass #joinery #restoration #london #kilburn
Stuffed peppers: filled with soaked fine bulgur wh Stuffed peppers: filled with soaked fine bulgur wheat, hazelnuts, sherry soaked sultanas, preserved lemon, smoky paprika, garlic, dill, coriander leaves , mint, and ground seeds, cumin,pumpkin seeds baked in the oven for 45 minutes. Serve with yoghurt. Delish! #latesummer #recipe #vegetarian #vegan #middleeasternish
My book Msmarmitelover’s secret tea party is now a My book Msmarmitelover’s secret tea party is now available on @ckbk which is like Spotify for cookbooks - check it out or buy a signed copy from my website #afternoonteaparty
Next door there are 2 damson trees in the grounds Next door there are 2 damson trees in the grounds of the council flats. The ground smelled like jam. I picked a few kilos, 3 kilos after sorting through. I put them, crushed, stones included, in a clean glass container, with 1.5 kilos of sugar and 2 litres of gin ( I may add another), I’ll leave them for 3/4 weeks then filter. Damson gin for Christmas.
Fig, chocolate and chestnut tart- recipe in my boo Fig, chocolate and chestnut tart- recipe in my book Msmarmitelover’s secret tea party. This is rather adult, using bitter dark chocolate ganache, chestnut flour and figs from my garden. #figrecipes #chocolate #baking
Went for an evening of Turkish music and entertain Went for an evening of Turkish music and entertainment @kibele.london Fantastic margarita cocktails, great food, generous portions and wonderful entertainment. In the end we all got up and had a go at belly dancing, #turkishfood #london #londonnights
I’ve got Covid (day3) so not much food in the hous I’ve got Covid (day3) so not much food in the house. I found some floppy- going black- carrots in the salad drawer, so I peeled and resuscitated those. Chopped them into a saucepan with a couple of cubes of vegetable stock and a litre of hot water. Then I added a couple of tablespoons of smooth peanut butter, a clove of garlic, 1 tsp of ground cumin, half a preserved lemon. Just stuff I had around. Simmered till the carrots were soft then blended in the @vitamixuk I can honestly say the vitamix is my most regularly used bit of kitchen kit. Anyway- hey presto- a high protein soup with fibre. I hope I test negative before I totally run out of food. #solo #covid #highprotein #soup
I wrote this long read for @scotnational about the I wrote this long read for @scotnational about the anti G8 camp in Stirling to protest against the G8 in Gleneagles. I partipated in the camp & protest along with my daughter @siennamarla playing in the samba band, part of the Pink Bloc. The camp was an incredible experience- the possibility of a different type of politics, of horizontal democracy. It was also a lot of fun. But our protest was tragically overshadowed by the 7/7 bombings in London. We wanted to create a new world but by the actions of a few disaffected British Muslim terrorists our positive movement for change was drowned out by hideous violence against normal ordinary people. Here is my account. 20 years anniversary #7/7 #londonbombings #scotland #antig8 #protest #gleneagles
Cheap stuff. Since the pandemic money has been tig Cheap stuff. Since the pandemic money has been tight. I shop at Lidl and aldi for food, Vinted, Portobello and Primark for clothes. The first pic is gazpacho with a banderilla from Lidl. They often have Spanish weeks and other nationality foods at a bargain price. I love those huge cartons of gazpacho- I glug it down like juice, especially in the heat. The banderillas are sold by the jar. Second pic is me in a primark vest, cardi, with an Anthropologie sale belt and old denim shorts from 10 years ago. Sorry about the mess behind, I sold a piece of furniture, a desk I found on the street, painted enamel green with ‘bamboo’brass handles which I sold on eBay for £225 #needsmust #thrift
My tea book Msmarmitelover’s secret tea party is n My tea book Msmarmitelover’s secret tea party is now out on the cookbook app @ckbk it’s now out of print but you can still buy some print copies via me or Amazon. However you can see all the recipes ( like my sour cherry icecream which I served last week) on this site which is like a Spotify for cooks. Arguably afternoon tea is a meal which the English do better than any other country. #cookbooks #afternoontea #supperclubs
Follow on Instagram

Archives

Copyright © 2025 msmarmitelover