• Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Snapchat
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

MsMarmiteLover

  • Food
    • Recipes
    • Vegetarian
    • Vegan
  • Travel
    • France
    • Italy
    • Spain
    • UK
  • Wine
  • Gardens
  • Supperclubs/Events
  • About
    • Published Articles
    • Books
  • Shop
    • Cart

Weighty matters

June 2, 2010 21 Comments Filed Under: Food, Recipes, Uncategorized

Sticks and cups, am I talking about a tarot pack or cooking measurements?
As any cook searching for recipes on the internet knows, this is how the ingredients in American recipes are measured. America likes to cook by volume rather than weight; they talk of ‘tablespoons’ of butter. Americans assume that the whole world buys butter in sticks and that we know how much it weighs (90g? 110g?). There is the added complication that American pounds, pints and quarts when used, contain a different amount of ounces to the British pound (an American quart is 32 fluid ounces, but 40 for a British, Australian, Kiwi quart). Worn out by the mental calculations, I have to admit an uncharitable thought crossed my mind, perhaps Americans are too thick to use scales? No, but this recent article in the Wall Street Journal states that U.S. cookbook publishers think that for Americans, “weights tend to look daunting”.
Precision, especially in baking, is essential. French baker Richard Bertinet is so keen on accuracy that he even recommends weighing water in grams rather than measuring millilitres in a jug.
Those casual references in recipes to a pinch of salt (1/16th of a teaspoon), a dash (1/8th) of vanilla essence, a smidgeon (1/32th) of spice, a glug ( a very quick down and up pour) of oil are micro measurements not to be taken lightly. Old recipe books always used visual quantities: a hen’s egg (1/4 of a cup), a pullet’s (a hen less than a year old) egg (slightly less) or a walnut of butter.
English cookbook writer Nigella Lawson famously adores, even sells the American system of cups and helpfully provides a conversion scale while the legendary American cook Alice Waters in The Art of Simple food stresses the importance of weighing.
Although I can understand the appeal of being able to picture an amount you might need for a recipe, I agree with Alice: a cup of flour is different depending on the weather, the humidity, the shakiness of your hand that day, the amount of gunk that is stuck in the bottom of your chosen container after the second or third cup. All these factors can affect the success of your recipe. I’ve worked out an American cup (even their cup sizes are different from ours) is 150g of flour, Nigella says it’s 140g and the Wall St Journal article says 120g sifted. That can make the difference between wasted ingredients and time; failure and success.
Another method is explained in a new book ‘Ratio: the Simples Codes Behind the Craft of Everyday Cooking’ by American author Michael Ruhlman who takes the traditional 1-2-3-4 (butter, sugar, flour, eggs) American cup ratio recipe for making a cake and applies it to all cooking. Professional chefs and bakers guard their ratios carefully as secrets of the trade. Ruhlman says that following ratios will ‘unchain you from recipes’ and gives a table: Bread-5 parts flour; 3 parts water (plus yeast and salt). Change this ratio slightly, 3 parts flour, 2 parts egg and it becomes pasta dough.
A reluctant converter to metric in other areas of life, I like inches, feet and yards as they are based on the natural measurements of the human body: an inch is a thumb (in French the words ‘inch’ and ‘thumb’ are identical: ‘pouce’), a yard is the distance between the end of your nose and the fingers of your arm outstretched. However in cooking I use grams and litres rather than the ounces and pounds of my childhood. What system do you use to measure? Are you comfortable with cups? Or do you groove to grams? How do you measure up?

Recent posts

Dutch Baby apple and cheese pancake

September 17, 2023

La bomba paella rice

August 25, 2023

No-churn ice cream recipes

August 7, 2023

Previous Post: « The Boy and me
Next Post: Some lovely things I’ve been making recently »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. bakelady59

    June 2, 2010 at 1:03 pm

    Being an 'Old Fashioned' Bakelady I have to confess to using imperial measuements. I prefer not to use cups because, as you say, they can be so inaccurate ie; do you tap the flour down in the cup before you measure it. A good pair of scales is essential, not those 'Arty' clock type Weighing scales where the arrow moves around and you cannot get an accurate measure. And never, never mix gramms with imperial, that's asking for desaster.

    Reply
  2. theundergroundrestaurant

    June 2, 2010 at 1:14 pm

    Yes I have some of the arty clock type scales which is merely on display and a flat digital scale which is what I actually use!

    Reply
  3. James

    June 2, 2010 at 3:03 pm

    Great diversionary tactic from writing.

    I think you can get carried away with accuracy. I just convert american weights to metric using conversion calculators you can easily google.

    Digital scales are great till the battery runs out – normally when you're flat out cooking and have no time to spare to buy one.

    There's probably one reason why nigella likes US measurments – helps sale of books.

    Reply
  4. Kavey

    June 2, 2010 at 4:28 pm

    When following recipes properly (rather than just taking them as a starting point or for inspiration) I do like to follow them accurately, so that I can make the recipe as it was created by the author. After that, I can make my own tweaks and adaptations according to my preferences and opinions on what would make it better.

    And to follow accurately, I prefer an accurate method of measurement.

    For me cups is so arbitrary. It just about works for fluids and powdered ingredients, though as you rightly point out, these can be affected by humidity amongst other factors.

    But what about when one sees cup measurements used for fruit and vegetables. "One cup diced onions" could vary immensely.

    Not to mention that a cup of peeled chopped this or that makes it virtually impossible for me to know how much to buy. If a recipe tells me 200 grams diced onions, I know to buy an onion that weighs a little over, to allow for peeling and discaring both ends. If I'm told I need a cup of diced onion I have no idea!

    For some types of cooking, especially once one is familiar, it's not so important to be accurate. We can go by instinct, a little. Only when we have the experience, of course.

    For other types of cooking, and for any that is unfamiliar, accuracy helps.

    Reply
  5. Lyndsay Anderson

    June 2, 2010 at 7:10 pm

    I have to say, I love the US system, it is so simple and the little cups tidy away so neatly. I'm no baker so anything that makes life a little easier gets my vote!

    Reply
  6. Kylie

    June 2, 2010 at 9:07 pm

    I grew up in Australia with the Australian Women's Weekly recipes, all in cups. This how I learnt to bake, and I never had a disaster. In fact as a poor and poverty stricken student I used a tea cup or a mug, and still managed to bake successfully.

    However now I use grams, my fly-by-the-seat-of-your-pants attitude has deserted me, and accuracy is important.

    I do have a set of Nigella cups for emergencies (like this afternoon's chocolate cheese cake, an Aussie recipe)

    Reply
  7. theundergroundrestaurant

    June 2, 2010 at 10:17 pm

    James: isnt it? good point tho re books.
    Kavey: it is odd isn't it?
    Lyndsey: when it comes to baking, accuracy is essential. In the past, too often I tried to freestyle it…it didn't work
    Kylie: in Australia do they use cups generally?

    Reply
  8. Sally

    June 3, 2010 at 3:16 am

    I have cup measurements for when I try an American recipe but it often means you have an extra thing to wash up or for the ingredients to stick to. Have you ever measured a cup of butter or fat and then tried to prise it out? Much easier in my opinion to weigh it on digital scales directly into the bowl you are about to mix it in. Your earlier post about making marmite cupcakes was brilliantly accurate and thanks for the tip about weighing the amount you put in each cake 'well'. As you say baking needs accuracy – however I detest this sort of prescriptive direction in other types of recipe. Why would you measure a tablespoon of olive oil when frying something? I think it's the stubborn side of me not wanting to be told what to do!

    Reply
  9. JJ

    June 3, 2010 at 8:55 am

    My go-to cookbook is the Joy of Cooking (I'm American) and I use cups, tablespoons and the like when using it, except for butter where I use 1T = 1/2 oz.

    I love my scale, too, and miss it when I'm in the US. I have a 10year old Salter digital scale which weighs to the gram or 1/4 ounce.

    Reply
  10. Anonymous

    June 3, 2010 at 9:22 am

    There's no such thing as a Kiwi quart! No one would have any idea what you're talking about (in fact I don't have a clue what a quart is)

    However I grew up using cups, although weights were given in some recipes. There didn't seem to be any set standard. In Home Ec we were taught to measure things in cups – pack the sugar down tightly, use a knife to even off the flour, never shake it.

    These days I far prefer scales though. I had a fit the other day when my Salter scales (with a 15 year guarantee) broke after six months of use. Had to go out early on a Saturday morning to replace them as I couldn't do without.

    Reply
  11. The Curious Cat

    June 3, 2010 at 10:53 am

    I hate having to weigh out stuff – I'm a real just bung it in girl. I often don't have scales to hand so I just use a tablespoon where I can and use google to assist with conversions…not going to work with baking really I know…need to get into better habits!

    Reply
  12. Jules

    June 3, 2010 at 1:54 pm

    I usually use kg/g with the odd tsp/tbsp . I just don't feel confident or trust using cups as I feel there is such a huge margin of error.

    As for scales I have a great set of flat digital scales, but when the battery decides to die I have a pair of traditinal scales with weights down to 5g.

    Reply
  13. theundergroundrestaurant

    June 3, 2010 at 10:04 pm

    When it comes to savoury i'm a bung it in girl too….but baking…that's a recipe for disaster!

    Reply
  14. Plum Kitchen

    June 4, 2010 at 12:01 am

    I struggle a bit with some of my older cookbooks, never having had to use imperial, grams & kg on a digital scale are the go really. I was given a set of Nigella measuring cups as a gift,I promptly dropped and cracked the cup and lost the 1/2 cup (?),but the 1/4 cup works perfectly for measuring my cat's bikkies (she is a very posh puss)and if I ever need to measure a 1/3 of a cup of anything, I do still have that one left…..

    Reply
  15. Animal Disco

    June 4, 2010 at 10:35 am

    This isn't really from me, but from Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall's recent Guardian feature on making Victoria sponge:

    "You'll notice in my recipe's ingredients list that I'm a little light on numbers. This isn't some dreadful error on my part, nor some go-as-you-please hippyishness. No, I'm following in the path of that quintessentially Victorian figure Mrs Beeton, who laid out the classic recipe for the Victoria sponge in her 1861 Book Of Household Management. In her recipe, the cake is made from equal quantities of eggs, butter, sugar and flour. You simply weigh the eggs in their shells and then measure out the same amount of butter, sugar and flour. So if the eggs just happen to weigh 250g, then you want a 250g block of butter and 250g of everything else. They won't, of course, but you must do what the eggs tell you – that's the fun of it."

    Fun? Aaaargh!!!!

    AD x

    Reply
  16. theundergroundrestaurant

    June 4, 2010 at 11:49 am

    Oh wow Animal disco, that's worth a try isn't it?

    Reply
  17. Ann

    June 5, 2010 at 12:57 pm

    I'm now comfortable with cups and weights, though I have written down what a cup of butter weighs. My new, digital scales were worth the cost and I mostly use grammes these days, rather than imperial measurements. However, I also guess a lot.

    Reply
  18. theundergroundrestaurant

    June 5, 2010 at 1:00 pm

    Ann: How many grams is a cup of butter? Just out of interest…

    Reply
  19. marv

    June 7, 2010 at 2:13 pm

    I'm a scientist by day so it will be no surprise that I measure everything by weight(including liquids as measuring jugs aren't very accurate) using digital scales and always use grams. I often scale recipes up or down and my brain cannot do that in imperial measuremtns.

    Animal Disco raises a good point about eggs though as these vary in size. To my shame I generally weigh these too… especially if I am making macarons or meringues. The ratio iphone app is brilliant for this as you can input the weight of your eggs and the app automatically adjusts the other ingredient quantities.

    Reply
  20. Lisa

    June 10, 2010 at 5:51 am

    I've just started reading Ratio, have been meaning to get it for ages and your post reminded me. It's great.

    I use Deb's conversions on Smitten Kitchen's site, and info cobbled together from elsewhere. For butter conversion I follow:

    1 stick = 4oz = 8tbsp = 1/2 cup = 112g

    When converting recipes I tend to leave cups for wet ingredients although I need a second set of measuring cups to avoid having to wash up repeatedly!

    Reply
  21. Ann

    June 14, 2010 at 8:25 am

    According to my calculations a cup of butter is 220 grammes.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Primary Sidebar

MsMarmiteLover aka Kerstin Rodgers.

Chef, photographer, author, journalist, blogger. Pioneer of the supperclub movement.

This is my food and travel blog, with recipes, reviews and travel stories. I also stray into politics, feminism, gardening.

Subscribe to my mailing list

msmarmitelover

Kerstin Rodgers/MsMarmiteLover
Apple rose blossom tarts with rose jam. Rose Appl Apple rose blossom tarts with rose jam.  Rose Apple Blossom Tarts

Serves 8

Equipment: 
Microwave
Cupcake or muffin tin

I use a red-skinned apple to make these, to get a hint of blush at the edges of the ‘petals’.

Ingredients:
4 Pink Lady or Royal Gala apples, cored, cut into quarters, sliced thinly into half moons
1 lemon, squeezed
1 pack all butter readymade puff pastry 320g, on a roll, cut into 8 strips about 6 cms long
100g of melted butter
1/2 jar of rose jam
1 or 2 tbsp cinnamon or cardamom, ground 
Pinch maldon salt
2 or 3 tbsp icing sugar

Instructions

Prepare a bowl of acidulated water (cold water with lemon juice) to prevent browning.
Core the apples, and cut them in quarters. Slice thinly into half-moons (a mandolin is useful for this). 
Put them into a large bowl of cold water with the lemon.
Microwave the bowl of sliced apples for 5 minutes until soft enough to bend slightly but not cook them.
Preheat the oven to 180ºC.
Roll out the puff pastry. Divide into 8 sections by cutting the roll into quarters then halving each quarter. You will end up with 8 approximately 6cm strips.
Brush the strip with melted butter then paint with a layer of rose jam. You can then dust with either ground cinnamon or cardamom.
Lay the apple slices along the top of the pastry strip, overlapping them. Fold up the bottom half of the pastry strip to make an pleat with the skin side of the apple half moon poking over the top.
Roll up the folded pastry strips until they look like a rose made of apple at the top
Place ‘rose’ side up, in a buttered cupcake tin
Repeat until all are done and bake for 20 -30 minutes.
Using a tea strainer or small sieve, sprinkle with icing sugar.
A lovely vegetarian recipe from @lulugargari - a g A lovely vegetarian recipe from @lulugargari - a green bean and basil pesto with Italian lemon 🍋 pasta. Fresh, light. This was at an Italian cooking class/demo @eatalylondon hosted by @ilovefruitandvegfromeuropecouk @flickflock #london#italy🇮🇹
Digital chefs came from Italy yesterday to teach h Digital chefs came from Italy yesterday to teach how to make pumpkin, chilli, taleggio fondue Paccheri pasta- warming and filling for autumn days. Thanks to @ilovefruitandvegfromeuropecouk @flickflock @eatalylondon @danielerossichef @lulugargari for the event. We then got to go shopping in Italy with a £50 voucher. I spent it on mostardi di frutta, burratta, carciofi, cheeses,. My sis in law @bro0907 spent it on two bottles of wine. 😂 #italianfood #italianingredients #cookingclass #campaniafood
Inspired by @kathybrownstev’s book on edible flo Inspired by @kathybrownstev’s book on edible flowers I did an edible flower supper club featured in my first book ‘supper club’ This weekend I briefly visited her garden. Decades of work and creativity went into creating this English oasis. It’s an hour and a half out of london near Bedford. It closes at the end of September: open Tuesdays and this coming weekend. It was odd to go on holiday so near to where I live! We had a beautiful Airbnb in Pavenham. The countryside starts nearer to home than I thought. #uk #england #gardens
Visited The speciality fine food fair today for th Visited The speciality fine food fair today for the first time. So many tastings! Great to see new products. Particularly impressed by @lamiriharissa which is smoked and delicious run by Jo Lamiri’s children and @quirkymonkeycoffee which is mushroom infused coffee and hot chocolate run by an autistic guy Darwin setting up his own business. Good for him. #foodexplorer
Bones and all. Just made tomato sauce pasta from m Bones and all. Just made tomato sauce pasta from my home made sun dried tomato concentrate made @tenutacammarana in Sicily last summer. It’s the taste of sunshine. Plus my English home-grown tomatoes. #Tomatoes 🍅 🍅 🍅 #dinner #babyledweaning
I’ve made a South African/ Botswana dish that is I’ve made a South African/ Botswana dish that is creamy samp with chakalaka. Samp is corn like hominy or pozole a native Indian or Mexican food. It’s strange that it’s a staple food in Africa. Corn is a new world good I think. Samp itself is quite bland, often eaten with beans. Chakalaka is delicious with peppers, Piri piri seasoning, ginger garlic onions tomatoes and carrots and baked beans.
Samp from Botswana. It’s husked corn and makes a Samp from Botswana. It’s husked corn and makes a porridge like carb- creamy samp. I’m rinsing, soaking and cooking today and will combine it with chakalaka tomorrow. #southafrica #botswana #samp #newworldoldworld
Did my living room floor with @woca_denmark_uk_ire Did my living room floor with @woca_denmark_uk_ireland natural floor soap yesterday which smells lovely. But high traffic areas need rewarding. This is a Scandinavian technique- regularly waxing pale wood floors. I did this floor during the first year of lockdown. I prefer waxed floors to varnished. #interiors #woodfloors
Handbag condiments: @tajinuk , salt @maldonsalt do Handbag condiments: @tajinuk , salt @maldonsalt do a great little handbag tin, soy sauce bottles, and of course a handbag @marmite . I’ve also been known to carry a handbag @wd40uk and a handbag @cremedecassis to make poor white wine drinkable. What do you carry in your bag? Are you like Beyoncé and carry hot sauce in your bag?
Alliums in a purple pot. Note to self: plant more Alliums in a purple pot. Note to self: plant more bobble headed alliums. Love the colour and shape. This is in a neighbours garden who I met on Saturday while working in the front garden. Traditionally the British have front gardens but now they are turned into driveways and building are developed into flats. Only very rich people in london can afford houses. But the front is very important for the community- it’s how you meet your neighbours. On Saturday I visited 2 different sets of neighbours gardens- the first time since I moved to this street 23 years ago. Our front garden is communal and has been an unloved space- I’m trying to change that. Tonight I cleaned all the wheely bins. A yucky job but otherwise they smell so bad in summer. I was thinking about all the terrible dirty jobs that someone has to do- clearing up after a road accident, or sorting out sewers, or unblocking toilets. The stuff that nobody likes to think about. #frontgardens #neighbours #londoners
What I’ve been up to: awning from @victorianawni What I’ve been up to: awning from @victorianawnings which has transformed our al fresco eating possibilities. Also been working on the front garden of our building using talented work men I found on fb marketplace: railings by @lincsecproducts ( the gates were bought by me some years ago and I’ve scraped off the rust and repainted), the arch, which took me 3 years to find on fb marketplace for the right price and size. The wisteria which will grow over the arch planted by @christina_erskine ( I’ve always wanted a wisteria and they apparently add to the value of your house), the Swiss style bike/buggy shed. Needs to be painted dark green to match the walls. My friend Jim repaired the walls, the coping, and laid the  concrete plinth. Now need to find coping for the pillars or perhaps urns for more plants. 47cm2. #interiors #exteriordesign #gates #railings #bikeshed #awning #design
Made a vegetarian paella with La bomba rice from @ Made a vegetarian paella with La bomba rice from @brindisaspanishfoods I used red and green peppers, saffron, sherry, Nyora peppers, smoked almonds and green olives #vegetarian #vegetariansummer #paella
Quick snap of my bedroom chimney wall with the @sa Quick snap of my bedroom chimney wall with the @sanderson1860 wallpaper - finally done. Never wallpapered before. By the way I’m totally open to interiors collaborations email me: marmitelover@mac.com #interiordesign #wallpaper #london
I was sent some incredible olive oil from Sicily b I was sent some incredible olive oil from Sicily by fattoriabaronemocciarolidestri Terrediequila wonderful quality. Intense new grassy flavours. #oliveoil #sicily
Cooking powders or flavour bombs: two of my favour Cooking powders or flavour bombs: two of my favourite are ‘chaat’ which you can buy in Indian shops- here I’ve sprinkled yoghurt with lime/achaar chaat and decorated with day lily petals. My other favourite culinary powder is @tajinuk which gives instant mexicanness to any dish. #tajin #chaat
Me and my beautiful granddaughter Ophelia. I look Me and my beautiful granddaughter Ophelia. I look a mess ( really need to dye hair but it’s sooo expensive) but I don’t care because my heart just bursts when I cuddle this little being who has been in my life for 8 months. Babies are a blessing. #granfluencer pic: @clairebelljar
Made arepas last week with masarepa, a precooked m Made arepas last week with masarepa, a precooked maize meal, topped with Wensleydale cheese which isn’t too dissimilar to a fresh Latin American cheese. I also added fresh corn kernels for texture. #colombia #venezuela #arepas #vegetarian
Quinoa salad cooked in a mushroom stock cube solut Quinoa salad cooked in a mushroom stock cube solution with hazelnuts & preserved lemons, home grown curly parsley. I’m not cooking most of my grains in a rice steamer. Turn out fluffy & perfect every time. #quinoa #grainbowl #summerfood
I took this photo of Jane Birkin when she performe I took this photo of Jane Birkin when she performed at @theroundhouse in 2008. Shabby chic with a sweet voice. #RIP #janebirkin #concert #london #rockphotographer
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Archives

Copyright © 2023 msmarmitelover